The Wrong Hand

by Melville Davisson Post

　　ABNER NEVER WOULD have taken me into that house if he could have helpedit. He was on a desperate mission and a child was the last company hewished; but he had to do it. It was an evening of early winter-raw andcold. A chilling rain was beginning to fall; night was descending and Icould not go on. I had been into the upcountry and had taken this shortcut through the hills that lay here against the mountains. I would havebeen home by now, but a broken shoe had delayed me.

　　I did not see Abner's horse until I approached the crossroads, but Ithink he had seen me from a distance. His great chestnut stood in thegrassplot between the roads, and Abner sat upon him like a man of stone.He had made his decision when I got to him.

　　The very aspect of the land was sinister. The house stood on a hill;round its base, through the sodded meadows, the river ran-dark, swiftand silent; stretching westward was a forest and for background thegreat mountains stood into the sky. The house was very old. The highwindows were of little panes of glass and on the ancient white door thepaint was seamed and cracked with age.

　　The name of the man who lived here was a byword in the hills. He was ahunchback, who sat his great roan as though he were a spider in thesaddle. He had been married more than once; but one wife had gone mad,and my Uncle Abner's drovers had found the other on a summer morningswinging to the limb of a great elm that stood before the door, abridle-rein knotted around her throat and her bare feet scattering theyellow pollen of the ragweed. That elm was to us a duletree. One couldnot ride beneath it for the swinging of this ghost.

　　The estate, undivided, belonged to Gaul and his brother. This brotherlived beyond the mountains. He never came until he came that last time.Gaul rendered some accounting and they managed in that way. It was saidthe brother believed himself defrauded and had come finally to dividethe lands; but this was gossip. Gaul said his brother came upon a visitand out of love for him.

　　One did not know where the truth lay between these stories. Why he camewe could not be certain; but why he remained was beyond a doubt.

　　One morning Gaul came to my Uncle Abner, clinging to the pommel of hissaddle while his great horse galloped, to say that he had found hisbrother dead, and asking Abner to go with some others and look upon theman before one touched his body-and then to get him buried.

　　The hunchback sniveled and cried out that his nerves were gone withgrief and the terror of finding his brother's throat cut open and theblood upon him as he lay ghastly in his bed. He did not know a detail.He had looked in at the door-and fled. His brother had not got up and hehad gone to call him. Why his brother had done this thing he could notimagine-he was in perfect health and he slept beneath his roof in love.The hunchback had blinked his red-lidded eyes and twisted his big, hairyhands, and presented the aspect of grief. It looked grotesque andloathsome; but-how else could a toad look in his extremity?

　　Abner had gone with my father and Elnathan Stone. They had found the manas Gaul said-the razor by his hand and the marks of his fingers and hisstruggle on him and about the bed. And the country had gone to see himburied. The hills had been afire with talk, but Abner and my father andElnathan Stone were silent. They came silent from Gaul's house; theystood silent before the body when it was laid out for burial; and,bareheaded, they were silent when the earth received it.

　　A little later, however, when Gaul brought forth a will, leaving thebrother's share of the estate to the hunchback, with certain lovingwords, and a mean allowance to the man's children, the three had mettogether and Abner had walked about all night.

　　As we turned in toward the house Abner asked me if I had got my supper.I told him "Yes"; and at the ford he stopped and sat a moment in thesaddle.

　　"Martin," he said, "get down and drink. It is God's river and the waterclean in it."

　　Then he extended his great arm toward the shadowy house.

　　"We shall go in," he said; "but we shall not eat nor drink there, for wedo not come in peace."

　　I do not know much about that house, for I saw only one room in it; thatwas empty, cluttered with dust and rubbish, and preempted by the spider.Long double windows of little panes of glass looked out over the dark,silent river slipping past without a sound, and the rain driving intothe forest and the loom of the mountains. There was a fire-the trunk ofan apple tree burning, with one end in the fireplace. There were someold chairs with black hair-cloth seats, and a sofa-all very old. Thesethe hunchback did not sit on, for the dust appeared when they weretouched. He had a chair beside the hearth, and he sat in that-ahigh-backed chair, made like a settee and padded-the arms padded too;but there the padding was worn out and ragged, where his hands hadplucked it.

　　He wore a blue coat, made with little capes to hide his hump, and he sattapping the burning tree with his cane. There was a gold piece set intothe head of this black stick. He had it put there, the gossips said,that his fingers might be always on the thing he loved. His gray hairlay along his face and the draft of the chimney moved it.

　　He wondered why we came, and his eyes declared how the thing disturbedhim; they flared up and burned down-now gleaming in his head as helooked us over, and now dull as he considered what he saw.

　　The man was misshapen and doubled up, but there was strength and vigorin him. He had a great, cavernous mouth, and his voice was a sort ofbellow. One has seen an oak tree, dwarfed and stunted into knots, butwith the toughness and vigor of a great oak in it. Gaul was a thing likethat.

　　He cried out when he saw Abner. He was taken by surprise; and he wishedto know if we came by chance or upon some errand.

　　"Abner," he said, "come in. It's a devil's night-rain and the drivingwind."

　　"The weather," said Abner, "is in God's hand."

　　"God!" cried Gaul. "I would shoestrap such a God! The autumn is not halfover and here is winter come, and no pasture left and the cattle to befed."

　　Then he saw me, with my scared white face-and her was certain that wecame by chance. He craned his thick neck and looked.

　　"Bub," he said, "come in and warm your fingers. I will not hurt you. Idid not twist my body up like this to frighten children-it was Abner'sGod."

　　We entered and sat down by the fire. The apple tree blazed and crackled;the wind outside increased; the rain turned to a kind of sleet thatrattled on the window-glass like shot. The room was lighted by twocandles in tall brass candlesticks. They stood at each end of themantelpiece, smeared with tallow. The wind whooped and spat into thechimney; and now and then a puff of wood-smoke blew out and mounted upalong the blackened fireboard.

　　Abner and the hunchback talked of the price of cattle, of the "blackleg"among yearlings-that fatal disease that we had so much trouble with-andof the "lump-jaw."

　　Gaul said that if calves were kept in small lots and not all togetherthe "blackleg" was not so apt to strike them; and he thought the"lump-jaw" was a germ. Fatten the bullock with green corn and put it ina car, he said, when the lump begins to come. The Dutch would eat it-andwhat poison could hurt the Dutch! But Abner said the creature should beshot.

　　"And lose the purchase money and a summer's grazing?" cried Gaul. "NotI! I ship the beast."

　　"Then," said Abner, "the inspector in the market ought to have it shotand you fined to boot."

　　"The inspector in the market!" And Gaul laughed. "Why, I slip him agreenback-thus!"-and he set his thumb against his palm. "And he is gladto see me. 'Gaul, bring in all you can,' said one; 'it means a littlesomething to us both.'" And the hunchback's laugh clucked and chuckledin his throat.

　　And they talked of renters, and men to harvest the hay and feed thecattle in the winter. And on this topic Gaul did not laugh; he cursed.Labor was a lost art and the breed of men run out. This new set wereworthless-they had hours-and his oaths filled all the rafters. Hours!Why, under his father men worked from dawn until dark and cleaned theirhorses by a lantern...These were decadent times that we were on. In thegood days one bought a man for two hundred eagles; but now the creaturewas a citizen and voted at the polls-and could not be kicked. And if onetook his cane and drubbed him he was straightway sued at law, in anaction of trespass on the case, for damages...Men had gone mad withthese newfangled notions, and the earth was likely to grow up withweeds!

　　Abner said there was a certain truth in this-and that truth was that menwere idler than their fathers. Certain preachers preached that labor wasa curse and backed it up with Scripture; but he had read the Scripturesfor himself and the curse was idleness. Labor and God's Book would savethe world; they were two wings that a man could get his soul to Heavenon.

　　"They can all go to hell, for me," said Gaul, "and so I have my day'swork first."

　　And he tapped the tree with his great stick and cried out that hisworkhands robbed him. He had to sit his horse and watch or they hungtheir scythes up; and he must put sulphur in his cattle's meal or theystole it from him; and they milked his cows to feed their scurvy babies.He would have their hides off if it were not for these tender laws.

　　Abner said that, while one saw to his day's work done, he must see tosomething more; that a man was his brother's keeper in spite of Cain'sdenial-and he must keep him; that the elder had his right to the day'swork, but the younger had also his right to the benefits of hisbrother's guardianship. The fiduciary had One to settle with. It wouldgo hard if he should shirk the trust.

　　"I do not recognize your trust," said Gaul. "I live here for myself."

　　"For yourself!" cried Abner. "And would you know what God thinks ofyou?"

　　"And would you know what I think of God?" cried Gaul.

　　"What do you think of Him?" said Abner.

　　"I think He's a scarecrow," said Gaul. "And I think, Abner, that I am awiser bird than you are. I have not sat cawing in a tree, afraid of thisthing. I have seen its wooden spine under its patched jacket, and thecrosspiece peeping from the sleeves, and its dangling legs. And I havegone down into its field and taken what I liked in spite of its flappingcoattails...Why, Abner, this thing your God depends on is a thingcalled fear; and I do not have it."

　　Abner looked at him hard, but he did not answer. He turned, instead, tome.

　　"Martin," he said, "you must go to sleep, lad." And he wrapped me in hisgreatcoat and put me to bed on the sofa-behind him in the corner. I wassnug and warm there and I could have slept like Saul, but I was curiousto know what Abner came for and I peeped out through a buttonhole of thegreatcoat.

　　Abner sat for a long time, his elbows on his knees, his hands togetherand his eyes looking into the fire. The hunchback watched him, his big,hairy hands moving on the padded arms of his chair and his sharp eyestwinkling like specks of glass. Finally Abner spoke-I judged he believedme now asleep.

　　"And so, Gaul," he said, "you think God is a scarecrow?"

　　"I do," said Gaul.

　　"And you have taken what you liked?"

　　"I have," said Gaul.

　　"Well," said Abner, "I have come to ask you to return what you havetaken-and something besides, for usury."

　　He got a folded paper out of his pocket and handed it across the hearthto Gaul.

　　The hunchback took it, leaned back in his chair, unfolded it at hisleisure and at his leisure read it through.

　　"A deed in fee," he said, "for all these lands...to my brother'schildren. The legal terms are right: 'Doth grant, with covenants ofgeneral warranty.'...It is well drawn, Abner; but I am not pleased to'grant.'"

　　"Gaul," said Abner, "there are certain reasons that may move you."

　　The hunchback smiled.

　　"They must be very excellent to move a man to alienate his lands."

　　"Excellent they are," said Abner. "I shall mention the best one first."

　　"Do," said Gaul, and his grotesque face was merry.

　　"It is this," said Abner: "You have no heirs. Your brother's son is nowa man; he should marry a wife and rear up children to possess theselands. And, as he is thus called upon to do what you cannot do, Gaul, heshould have the things you have, to use."

　　"That's a very pretty reason, Abner," said the hunchback, "and it doesyou honor; but I know a better."

　　"What is it, Gaul?" said Abner.

　　The hunchback grinned. "Let us say, my pleasure!"

　　Then he struck his bootleg with his great black stick.

　　"And now," he cried, "who's back of this tomfoolery?"

　　"I am," said Abner.

　　The hunchback's heavy brows shot down. He was not disturbed, but he knewthat Abner moved on no fool's errand.

　　"Abner," he said, "you have some reason for this thing. What is it?"

　　"I have several reasons for it," replied Abner, "and I gave you the bestone first."

　　"Then the rest are not worth the words to say them in," cried Gaul.

　　"You are mistaken there," replied Abner; "I said that I would give youthe best reason, not the strongest...Think of the reason I have given.We do not have our possessions in fee in this world, Gaul, but uponlease and for a certain term of service. And when we make default inthat service the lease abates and a new man can take the title."

　　Gaul did not understand and he was wary.

　　"I carry out my brother's will," he said.

　　"But the dead," replied Abner, "cannot retain dominion over things.There can be no tenure beyond a life estate. These lands and chattelsare for the uses of men as they arrive. The needs of the living overrulethe devises of the dead."

　　Gaul was watching Abner closely. He knew that this was some digression,but he met it with equanimity. He put his big, hairy fingers togetherand spoke with a judicial air.

　　"Your argument," he said, "is without a leg to stand on. It is the deadwho govern. Look you, man, how they work their will upon us! Who havemade the laws? The dead! Who have made the customs that we obey and thatform and shape our lives? The dead! And the titles to our lands-have notthe dead devised them?...If a surveyor runs a line he begins at somecorner that the dead set up; and if one goes to law upon a question thejudge looks backward through his books until he finds out how the deadhave settled it-and he follows that. And all the writers, when theywould give weight and authority to their opinions, quote the dead; andthe orators and all those who preach and lecture-are not their mouthsfilled with words that the dead have spoken? Why, man, our lives followgrooves that the dead have run out with their thumbnails!"

　　He got on his feet and looked at Abner. "What my brother has written inhis will I will obey," he said. "Have you seen that paper, Abner?"

　　"I have not," said Abner, "but I have read the copy in the countyclerk's book. It bequeathed these lands to you."

　　The hunchback went over to an old secretary standing against the wall.He pulled it open, got out the will and a pack of letters and broughtthem to the fire. He laid the letters on the table beside Abner's deedand held out the will.

　　Abner took the testament and read it.

　　"Do you know my brother's writing?" said Gaul.

　　"I do," said Abner.

　　'Then you know he wrote that will."

　　"He did," said Abner. "It is in Enoch's hand." Then he added: "But thedate is a month before your brother came here."

　　"Yes," said Gaul; "it was not written in this house. My brother sent itto me. See-here is the envelope that it came in, postmarked on thatdate."

　　Abner took the envelope and compared the date. "It is the very day," hesaid, "and the address is in Enoch's hand."

　　"It is," said Gaul; "when my brother had set his signature to this willhe addressed that cover. He told me of it." The hunchback sucked in hischeeks and drew down his eyelids. "Ah, yes," he said, "my brother lovedme!"

　　"He must have loved you greatly," replied Abner, "to thus disinherit hisown flesh and blood."

　　"And am not I of his own flesh and blood too?" cried the hunchback. "Thestrain of blood in my brother runs pure in me; in these children it isdiluted. Shall not one love his own blood first?"

　　"Love!" echoed Abner. "You speak the word, Gaul-but do you understandit?"

　　"I do," said Gaul; "for it bound my brother to me."

　　"And did it bind you to him?" said Abner.

　　I could see the hunchback's great white eyelids drooping and hislengthened face.

　　"We were like David and Jonathan," he said. "I would have given my rightarm for Enoch and he would have died for me."

　　"He did!" said Abner.

　　I saw the hunchback start, and, to conceal the gesture, he stooped andthrust the trunk of the apple tree a little farther into the fireplace.A cloud of sparks sprang up. A gust of wind caught the loose sash in thecasement behind us and shook it as one, barred out and angry, shakes adoor. When the hunchback rose Abner had gone on.

　　"If you loved your brother like that," he said, "you will do him thisservice-you will sign this deed."

　　"But, Abner," replied Gaul, "such was not my brother's will. By the law,these children will inherit at my death. Can they not wait?"

　　"Did you wait?" said Abner.

　　The hunchback flung up his head.

　　"Abner," he cried, "what do you mean by that?" And he searched myuncle's face for some indicatory sign; but there was no sign there-theface was stern and quiet.

　　"I mean," said Abner, "that one ought not to have an interest inanother's death."

　　"Why not?" said Gaul.

　　"Because," replied Abner, "one may be tempted to step in before theprovidence of God and do its work for it."

　　Gaul turned the innuendo with a cunning twist.

　　"You mean," he said, "that these children may come to seek my death?"

　　I was astonished at Abner's answer.

　　"Yes," he said; "that is what I mean."

　　"Man," cried the hunchback, "you make me laugh!"

　　"Laugh as you like," replied Abner; "but I am sure that these childrenwill not look at this thing as we have looked at it."

　　"As who have looked at it?" said Gaul.

　　"As my brother Rufus and Elnathan Stone and I," said Abner.

　　"And so," said the hunchback, "you gentlemen have considered how to savemy life. I am much obliged to you." He made a grotesque, mocking bow."And how have you meant to save it?"

　　"By the signing of that deed," said Abner.

　　"I thank you!" cried the hunchback. "But I am not pleased to save mylife that way."

　　I thought Abner would give some biting answer; but, instead, he spokeslowly and with a certain hesitation.

　　"There is no other way," he said. "We have believed that the stigma ofyour death and the odium on the name and all the scandal would in theend wrong these children more than the loss of this estate during theterm of your natural life; but it is clear to me that they will not soregard it. And we are bound to lay it before them if you do not signthis deed. It is not for my brother Rufus and Elnathan Stone and me todecide this question."

　　"To decide what question?" said Gaul. "Whether you are to live or die!"said Abner. The hunchback's face grew stern and resolute. He sat down inhis chair, put his stick between his knees and looked my uncle in theeyes.

　　"Abner," he said, "you are talking in some riddle...Say the thing outplain. Do you think I forged that will?"

　　"I do not," said Abner.

　　"Nor could any man!" cried the hunchback. "It is in my brother'shand-every word of it; and, besides, there is neither ink nor paper inthis house. I figure on a slate; and when I have a thing to say I go andtell it."

　　"And yet," said Abner, "the day before your brother's death you boughtsome sheets of foolscap of the postmaster."

　　"I did," said Gaul-"and for my brother. Enoch wished to make somecalculations with his pencil. I have the paper with his figures on it."

　　He went to his desk and brought back some sheets.

　　"And yet," said Abner, "this will is written on a page of foolscap."

　　"And why not?" said Gaul. "Is it not sold in every store to Mexico?"

　　It was the truth-and Abner drummed on the table.

　　"And now," said Gaul, "we have laid one suspicion by looking it squarelyin the face; let us lay the other. What did you find about my brother'sdeath to moon over?"

　　"Why," said Abner, "should he take his own life in this house?"

　　"I do not know that," said Gaul.

　　"I will tell you," said Abner; "we found a bloody handprint on yourbrother!"

　　"Is that all that you found on him?"

　　"That is all," said Abner.

　　"Well," cried Gaul, "does that prove that I killed him? Let me look yourugly suspicion in the face. Were not my brother's hands covered with hisblood and was not the bed covered with his finger-prints, where he hadclutched about it in his death-struggle?"

　　"Yes," said Abner; "that is all true."

　　"And was there any mark or sign in that print," said Gaul, "by which youcould know that it was made by any certain hand"-and he spread out hisfingers-"as, for instance, my hand?"

　　"No," said Abner.

　　There was victory in Gaul's face.

　　He had now learned all that Abner knew and he no longer feared him.There was no evidence against him-even I saw that.

　　"And now," he cried, "will you get out of my house? I will have no morewords with you. Begone!"

　　Abner did not move. For the last five minutes he had been at work atsomething, but I could not see what it was, for his back was toward me.Now he turned to the table beside Gaul and I saw what he had been doing.He had been making a pen out of a goosequill! He laid the pen down onthe table and beside it a horn of ink. He opened out the deed that hehad brought, put his finger on a line, dipped the quill into the ink andheld it out to Gaul.

　　"Sign there!" he said.

　　The hunchback got on his feet, with an oath.

　　"Begone with your damned paper!" he cried.

　　Abner did not move.

　　"When you have signed," he said.

　　"Signed!" cried the hunchback. "I will see you and your brother Rufus,and Elnathan Stone, and all the kit and kittle of you in hell!"

　　"Gaul," said Abner, "you will surely see all who are to be seen inhell!"

　　By Abner's manner I knew that the end of the business had arrived. Heseized the will and the envelope that Gaul had brought from hissecretary and held them out before him.

　　"You tell me," he said, "that these papers were written at one sitting!Look! The hand that wrote that envelope was calm and steady, but thehand that wrote this will shook. See how the letters wave and jerk! Iwill explain it. You have kept that envelope from some old letter; butthis paper was written in this house-in fear! And it was written on themorning that your brother died...Listen! When Elnathan Stone steppedback from your brother's bed he stumbled over a piece of carpet. Theunder side of that carpet was smeared with ink, where a bottle had beenbroken. I put my finger on it and it was wet."

　　The hunchback began to howl and bellow like a beast penned in a corner.I crouched under Abner's coat in terror. The creature's cries filled thegreat, empty house. They rose a hellish crescendo on the voices of thewind; and for accompaniment the sleet played shrill notes on thewindowpanes, and the loose shingles clattered a staccato, and thechimney whistled-like weird instruments under a devil's fingers.

　　And all the time Abner stood looking down at the man-an implacable,avenging Nemesis-and his voice, deep and level, did not change.

　　"But, before that, we knew that you had killed your brother! We knew itwhen we stood before his bed. 'Look there,' said Rufus-'at that bloodyhandprint!'...We looked...And we knew that Enoch's hand had not madethat print. Do you know how we knew that, Gaul?...I will tell you...The bloody print on your brother's right hand was the print of a righthand!"

　　Gaul signed the deed, and at dawn we rode away, with the hunchback'spromise that he would come that afternoon before a notary andacknowledge what he had signed; but he did not come-neither on that daynor on any day after that.

　　When Abner went to fetch him he found him swinging from his elm tree.