Home
/
Non-Fiction
/
Black Earth
Black Earth
Apr 21, 2025 1:19 PM

Author:Timothy Snyder

Black Earth

LONGLISTED FOR THE 2015 SAMUEL JOHNSON PRIZE

We have come to see the Holocaust as a factory of death, organised by bureaucrats. Yet by the time the gas chambers became operation more than a million European Jews were already dead: shot at close range over pits and ravines. They had been murdered in the lawless killing zones created by the German colonial war in the East, many on the fertile black earth that the Nazis believed would feed the German people.

It comforts us to believe that the Holocaust was a unique event. But as Timothy Snyder shows, we have missed basic lessons of the history of the Holocaust, and some of our beliefs are frighteningly close to the ecological panic that Hitler expressed in the 1920s. As ideological and environmental challenges to the world order mount, our societies might be more vulnerable than we would like to think.

Timothy Snyder’s Bloodlands was an acclaimed exploration of what happened in eastern Europe between 1933 and 1945, when Nazi and Soviet policy brought death to some 14 million people. Black Earth is a deep exploration of the ideas and politics that enabled the worst of these policies, the Nazi extermination of the Jews. Its pioneering treatment of this unprecedented crime makes the Holocaust intelligible, and thus all the more terrifying.

Reviews

Timothy Snyder's bold new approach to the Holocaust links Hitler's racial worldview to the destruction of states and the quest for land and food. This insight leads to thought-provoking and disturbing conclusions for today's world. Black Earth uses the recent past's terrible inhumanity to underline an urgent need to rethink our own future

—— Ian Kershaw

A wholly readable and utterly persuasive attempt to get us to look at the Holocaust in a different light. I read it twice, aghast but gripped by the moral abyss into which I was plunged on each page

—— Observer

Black Earth is provocative, challenging, and an important addition to our understanding of the Holocaust. As he did in Bloodlands, Timothy Snyder makes us rethink those things we were sure we already knew

—— Deborah Lipstadt

Part history, part political theory, Black Earth is a learned and challenging reinterpretation

—— Henry A. Kissinger

In this unusual and innovative book, Timothy Snyder takes a fresh look at the intellectual origins of the Holocaust, placing Hitler's genocide firmly in the politics and diplomacy of 1930s Europe. Black Earth is required reading for anyone who cares about this difficult period of history

—— Anne Applebaum

Timothy Snyder’s Black Earth is not only a powerful exposure of the horrors of the Holocaust but also a compelling dissection of the Holocaust’s continuing threat

—— Zbigniew Brzezinski

Timothy Snyder is now our most distinguished historian of evil. Black Earth casts new light on old darkness. It demonstrates once and for all that the destruction of the Jews was premised on the destruction of states and the institutions of politics.I know of no other historical work on the Holocaust that is so deeply alarmed by its repercussions for the human future. This is a haunted and haunting book—erudite, provocative, and unforgettable

—— Leon Wieseltier

Timothy Snyder argues, eloquently and convincingly, that the world is still susceptible to the inhuman impulses that brought about the Final Solution. This book should be read as admonition by presidents, prime ministers, and in particular by anyone who believes that the past is somehow behind us

—— Jeffrey Goldberg

Always readable, highly sophisticated, and strikingly original

—— Bernard Wasserstein , Jewish Chronicle

Black Earth is mesmerizing

—— Edward Rothstein , Wall Street Journal (Europe)

an engrossing and often thought-provoking analysis of Hitler’s antisemitic ideology and an intelligently argued country-by-country survey of its implementation between 1939 and 1945

—— Richard J Evans , Guardian

A masterful work

—— Spectator

A passionate and semi-polemical account

—— David Aaronovitch , The Times

a wholly readable and utterly persuasive attempt to get us to look at the Holocaust in a different light

—— Nick Fraser , Observer

this is a deeply insightful and original treatment and, as the Holocaust drifts slowly but surely from living memory and into history, a warning against future complacency

—— John Owen , History Today

Snyder excels in repositioning the Holocaust in a global context

—— Joanna Bourke , New Statesman

Timothy Synder reorientates our understanding of the ideological structures and political circumstances that made the Nazis’ genocidal programme possible
·

—— John Owen , History Today

To his recalibration of the conventional topography and chronology of the Holocaust, Snyder adds a novel interpretation of Hitler’s worldview and of the place of Jews in it

—— Jonathan Derbyshire , Prospect

Snyder delivers what is surely the best and most unsparing analysis of eastern European collaborationism now available.

—— Richard J Evans , Guardian

As our world fragments and dissolves into chaos, Snyder offers a chilling lesson about how easy it is for people to slip into evil and bloodlust.

—— Catholic Herald

a book of the greatest importance… written with searing intellectual honesty.

—— Anthony Beevor , Sunday Times

Snyder's extraordinary book may be about events more than seventy years ago, but its lessons about human nature are as relevant now as then

—— Rebecca Tinsley , Independent Catholic News

Disturbing but utterly compelling... The how’s and whys of what happened have never been better explained.

—— Simon Shaw , Mail on Sunday

Highly praised, and indeed it is a worthy contribution to the subject.

—— Ruth Ginarlis , Nudge

Harding has recorded the fate of the house and its inhabitants, from the Weimar republic until reunification. This is German history in microcosm ... as exciting as a good historical novel.

—— Die Welt

An inspirational read: highly recommended.

—— Western Morning News

A genuinely remarkable work of biographical innovation.

—— Stuart Kelly , TLS, Books of the Year

I’d like to reread Ruth Scurr’s John Aubrey every Christmas for at least the next five years: I love being between its humane pages, which celebrate both scholarly companionship and deep feeling for the past

—— Alexandra Harris , Guardian

Ruth Scurr’s innovative take on biography has an immediacy that brings the 17th century alive

—— Penelope Lively , Guardian

Anyone who has not read Ruth Scurr’s John Aubrey can have a splendid time reading it this summer. Scurr has invented an autobiography the great biographer never wrote, using his notes, letters, observations – and the result is gripping

—— AS Byatt , Guardian

A triumph, capturing the landscape and the history of the time, and Aubrey’s cadence.

—— Daily Telegraph

A brilliantly readable portrait in diary form. Idiosyncratic, playful and intensely curious, it is the life story Aubrey himself might have written.

—— Jane Shilling , Daily Mail

Scurr knows her subject inside out.

—— Simon Shaw , Mail on Sunday

The diligent Scurr has evidence to support everything… Learning about him is to learn more about his world than his modest personality, but Scurr helps us feel his pain at the iconoclasm and destruction wrought by the Puritans without resorting to overwrought language.

—— Nicholas Lezard , Guardian

Acclaimed and ingeniously conceived semi-fictionalised autobiography… Scurr’s greatest achievement is to bring both Aubrey and his world alive in detail that feels simultaneously otherworldly and a mirror of our own age… It’s hard to think of a biographical work in recent years that has been so bold and so wholly successful.

—— Alexander Larman , Observer
Comments
Welcome to zzdbook comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.zzdbook.com All Rights Reserved